It is the will of Allah. In Februarythe Taliban, who once ruled in Afghanistan, ordered this punishment for three men convicted of sodomy:. On Wednesday, the Taleban ordered the execution of three men for sodomy in the southern town of Kandahar, southern Afghanistan.
They were Sharia law homosexuality to be buried alive under a pile of stones and a wall was pushed on top of them by a tank. Their lives were to be spared if they survived for 30 minutes and were still alive when the stones were removed. Simple Sharia law homosexuality clear reason says that executing homosexuals is wrong today, but where do the Taliban get the punishment of pushing a wall on the guilty men?
Also, the article reports that while the religious police were meting out a flogging on a woman for fornication, a speaker chanted, "Thanks to God that we are followers of God not of the West. In its Constitution, Iran adopted the extreme punishment of execution for sodomy. Sodomy is a crime, for which both partners are punished. The punishment is death if the participants are adults, of
Sharia law homosexuality mind and consenting; the method of execution is for the Shari'a judge to decide.
Later on, the summary of the Constitution says that if the guilty repent, the judge may waive the penalty. But Sharia law homosexuality this penalty exist in the first place? What is the source for this extreme law in the Iranian Constitution? On April 7,it was reported that Saudi Arabia sentenced more than men to prison or flogging for "gay conduct. On or about March 26, a Jeddah court, meeting in a closed session in which defense attorneys were excluded, sentenced 31 of the men to prison for six months to one year, and to lashes each, for unreported offenses.
Police released more than 70 of the men not long after their initial arrest; reports in the Saudi press suggested that personal contacts with the government had intervened on their behalf.
Have these radical judges left Islam? Execution, flogging, and toppling a wall on homosexuals come from the
Sharia law homosexuality hadith and later legal rulings in Islam.
They sit at its core. Execution and flogging may also come from the Quran itself.
To explain how these extremes are embedded in Islam and how Christianity offers a better solution, this article is divided up into three large sections: Islam, Christianity, and an Application, including supplemental material. The main section "Islam" is subdivided into three sections: When we analyze the Quran, we also provide the historical and literary contexts of the target verse, in order to avoid the standard, reflexive "out of context" defense from Muslims apologists defenders.
The main section "Christianity" is subdivided into four sections: After we analyze the two religions on the matter of homosexuality, we apply our findings to today, the third main section, including supplemental material.
However, as we shall see, the Quran is unclear on homosexuality in its legal punishments, but not in its immorality. While living in Mecca before his Hijrah Sharia law homosexuality ADMuhammad does
Sharia law homosexuality seem to have decreed an official punishment for homosexuals.
However, he frequently told stories about Lot, who lived in Sodom. This passage in Sura 7, representing others in Meccan suras chapterswas revealed late in Mecca, but scholars are rarely confident about the precise date of Meccan suras or chapters in the Quran. Remember that he said to his people, "Have you become so shameless that you commit such indecent acts as no one has committed before you in the world? Maududi, The Meaning of the Quranvol. In general terms this passage condemns homosexuality because it "transgresses the limits" of nature.
The punishment for the inhabitants of Sodom was a rainstorm, "We rained upon his people," which is based on Genesis 18 and If the readers would like to see Sura 7: The number 7 is the sura or chapter and are the verse numbers. Here are other that describe Lot and the Sodomites, whose main ideas overlap with 7: All of these verses denounce sodomy as a sin and report the destruction of Sodom by the sovereign act of God.
Even though these passages do not explicitly rule on punishing homosexuals in legal contexts, Muslims jurists have divine permission to impose human punishments on homosexuals, especially when the judges also include the hadith. We first analyze the historical and literary contexts. He is highly respected traditional commentator who says that this sura, itself titled "Women," was revealed at different times, but still in the timeframe of AD toin Medina, for Muhammad has already emigrated.
He is establishing his Muslim community in the face of opposition and adverse circumstances, though Islam manages to overcome them. Verse 34 fits into the framework of vv. For instance, in the aftermath of the Battle of Uhud inin which the Muslims lost a lot of men, Muhammad says that orphans should be given their property and not to replace their good things with bad, which means to deal fairly and wisely Sharia law homosexuality their assets vv.
This translation by Hilali and Khan, funded by the Saudi royal family, adds parenthetical glosses implied in the Arabic, but not original to it:. As to the women who commit illegal Sharia law homosexuality intercourse, this translation of v. Are they committing the sin with men or with women? But this translation interprets v.
Maududi says that Sura 4: Sayyid Qutb, the other commentator, was the godfather of modern jihadist movements who was executed in for trying to overthrow the Egyptian government.
In a section titled "First Step Towards Eradicating Sexual Immorality" wrongly implying that eradication is possible in the first place; see his next section, "A Perfectly Moral Society"he
Sharia law homosexuality that the two women "Sharia law homosexuality" committing lewd acts with men in v. Thus, according to Maududi and Qutb, confusion rules over v. Clarity is one of the frequent claims in the Quran, but this is untrue in this case. Finally, the end of v. Qutb rightly notes that these clauses represent an interim ruling because the words "until God gives them another way out" Haleem is open-ended.
And this is where Maududi and Qutb agree Maududi, vol. It should be recalled that Reliable hadith that many scholars connect to But if we isolate Sura Qutb cites a hadith that shows how Muhammad received this revelation of a "way out" in Sura 4: The Prophet used to be visibly affected every time revelations were bestowed on him from on high.
His face changed and he looked ill at ease. One day, after he received revelations and he regained his color, he said: God has opened another way out for them, both in the case of a married man and a married woman and that of an unmarried man and an unmarried woman. For the married, one hundred lashes and stoning, and for the unmarried one hundred lashes and exile for a
Sharia law homosexuality. Thus, the "way out" does not lead to forgiveness and restoration, but to flogging and stoning.
Muhammad has raised sexual sin to a crime, which means that it must be criminally Sharia law homosexuality in the same way
Sharia law homosexuality theft and highway robbery are criminally punished. To conclude this section, the Quran does not prescribe a clear way of dealing with homosexuality.
The sacred book condemns it in the stories about Lot, which were told during the Meccan period, but in the Medinan period, Sura 4: In this major area of human sexuality, the Muslim holy book comes up Sharia law homosexuality. So now we must turn to the hadith, where things are less ambiguous.
For more information on Sura 4: The four most reliable hadith collectors and editors are Bukhari d. The Quran and the hadith are the foundations for later legal rulings.
But in the matter Sharia law homosexuality homosexuality, the Quran is unclear, so the hadith guides Islam more clearly. The Prophet cursed effeminate men and those women who assume the similitude manners of men. He also said said: Thus, effeminate men and masculine women are cursed and driven out of the early Muslim community.
These men may not be homosexuals, but may have lost their sex drive or desire for women. Either way, rejection, not salvation, "Sharia law homosexuality" the rule in early Islam, under the guidance of Muhammad. The Sunan Abu Dawudnamed after its editor, is another reliable collection of hadith. The next one from the same collection says that an unmarried man who commits sodomy should be stoned to death: Rather, Ibn Abbas says that Muhammad and the early Muslim community commanded their execution.
In the same hadith collection, the Mishkhat al-Masabiha compendium that brings together other hadith collections, are found the punishments of being burned to death and having heavy objects thrown on the guilty homosexuals:.
In the introduction to this article, a news report says that the Taliban toppled a wall on two homosexuals. Now we know where they got this cruel and unusual punishment. Thus, the Taliban appears extreme to us and they arebut they are merely following early Islam. Hence, since this extremism comes from original Islam itself, so why would traditional Muslims who know their own religion well want to reform today? Ignore the core of their religion? The cognitive dissonance or mental shock would be too strong.
Pakistan, Zam Zam, In his commentary on Sura 4: regard to the method in which these people [homosexuals] are to executed, Abu Bakr after consulting with Ali and other Sahaaba [companions of Muhammad], ruled that they be burnt. Memri TV has a clip and a transcript of a modern scholar asserting that homosexuals should be thrown off a cliff.
The hadith punishments range from rejection and banishment to execution by terrible methods, such as being stoning, burned alive, or thrown "Sharia law homosexuality" a high point. It should be reiterated here that if later Islamic judges follow the punishment meted out in Sura In fact, they will impose some or all of these penalties, depending on the circumstances, as we now see in the next section. Sharia means the body of Islamic law rooted in the Quran and the hadith; fiqh means the science of interpreting and applying this law, done by qualified Islamic judges and legal scholars.
They base their legal opinions and rulings on the Quran and the hadith.
“The people of Lot,” or so the LGBT community is called by Muslims, It is part of Muslim Sharia law, shared commonly in Middle Eastern. There are currently eight countries in which homosexuality is In theory the death penalty could be handed down under sharia law in.
Iran: In accordance with sharia law, homosexual intercourse between men can be punished by death, and men can be flogged for Sharia law homosexuality acts.